Review : NYX Jumbo Eye Pencils
NYX is probably the number one drugstore brand that I really wish we had here in the Philippines. They are extremely affordable and although most of their products can be a hit or miss, if you are careful, you can find items that you are really going to treasure and may even be worth more than what you pay for. The first ever product that I bought from them are their NYX Jumbo Pencils. I was drawn to the chubby crayons concept and the really cheap price.
Strawberry Milk , Sparkle Nude, Yogurt, Cashmere, Cottage Cheese
First of all you have a large variety of colors to choose from, these are just my top five favorites. :) The packaging is very cute and easy going. You just slide it on your skin, blend it with your fingers, and slide it back again inside your make up pouch, and you’re good to go. While the packaging can be its strength it can also be its downfall because a portion of the product goes to waste when you sharpen the pencils, which is why I prefer pots. But the good thing about it being a pencil is you can use these both as an eye shadow and an eye liner.
Strawberry Milk
Its texture is very creamy and it glides on your skin easily. Kind of like the MAC paint pots. It is highly pigmented when applied on your skin at first. It blends easily but you have to be careful because the color can fade away very fast as you spread it on your eye lids. It will leave a very faint color and a lot of shimmer, which I didn’t like.
Yogurt
That’s why I think a primer is very important to use with these pencils. It is also better if your primer is skin tone colored to even out the base of your eye lids. This will make the colors pop and make the product last longer on your skin. You also have to keep in mind that they crease a lot, especially if your eye lids are oily. That’s the reason why I only picked colors that are more natural so I won’t really mind it when they crease. Besides there are make up looks that are better when the eye colors are a little bit creased and messy.
Sparkle Nude
It lasts for around five hours without a primer on me. After five hours the color will be weak and it won’t be that pretty anymore. I discovered that the darker colors (strawberry milk, sparkle nude, yogurt) lasted longer than the lighter ones – (cashmere and cottage cheese). For that reason I do not like using Cashmere and Cottage Cheese as a main eye shadow base unless of course I am putting another eye shadow on top of them.
Sparkle Nude
I like using them with my Urban Decay Naked eye shadows. Their colors are a good match, especially Sparkle Nude and Yogurt. I use UD as my main eye shadow, and use the jumbo pencils as an eye liner on my waterline or if I want to add more sparkle around my eyes. I just have to blend them out after applying so I don’t have a harsh metallic color under my eyes. They are also beautiful to apply on your tear duct and instantly brightens up your eyes.
Cottage Cheese
How ’bout you? I’m really interested to know which colors do you have and love? :)
NYX Jumbo Pencils ★★★★☆
Price is more or less PHP 150.00 depending on your retailer
This product has its ups and downs. They are very easy to use and can act as an eye shadow, eye liner, and sometimes even as a highlighter. The colors are wonderful but they can fade easily and crease with out a primer. Primer is a must when it comes to using this product. Overall I still think that this is a good purchase because it is very affordable and fun to use.
NYX website
logo from NYX’s website
102 Comments
Loving this and your blog!
http://www.theunwrittenstyle.blogspot.com
I find the colors a bit blah to be honest. They are so bland and I don't find them very exciting. I am usually a NYX fan but these pencils really don't excite me.
Gteat review like the strawberry milk and cottage cheese.
http://tifi11@blogspot.com
wow, those pencils look gorgeous! I need to try it! :) Let's follow each other on GFC and facebook? :)
http://www.coral-charm-style.blogspot.pt/
http://www.facebook.com/coralcharm.blog
the price there is so freaking cheap -envy-
:( I'm thinking moving there now..haha
Here in Malaysia we only can get a view in Sephora counter. Which means it's gonna be quite expensive for an NYX.
btw I nominate you in my Versatile Blogger Award here, please check if you got the time :)
Hey,unfortunately I´ve no good experience with eyeshadow pencils, the sparkling particles accentuate my lines stronger;-) But the colors are wonderful and your pics fab!
thx for these test!
best wishes
Anni
We also sadly don't have this brand here in SA, it looks like such great pencils, love the sparkly nude shade
I can't get NYX here. ;_; However, I ordered the white one (milk, I think) from eBay a couple of years ago and it's still going strong (shh, I know I should replace it). I don't find creasing is much of a problem, because I blend it in almost completely and use it just as an eye shadow base. It makes all my make-up colours look so much more vibrant. ^_^
sono troppo curiosa di provare questi matitoni!!ne sento troppo parlare!!^_^
This is a great review Shayne. Very thorough. :D
love the colors :)
i agree. we should have nyx here in the PH. :)
Thanks for sharing this. Really helpfull. I will try one of these for sure.
Have a nice day,
Julia
Hi Shayne! Thanks for stopping by my little blog :-)
I love NYX as well…and they are def hit or miss. Have you ever tried Milani, that is another drug store brand that I absolutely adore. They are pricier than NYX but the quality is amazing.
Here is a link to a post about my bag that you wanted a closer pic of :0)
http://morningbirdee.blogspot.ca/2012/03/juicy-reveal.html
Have a great day!!
~Jane B
I just bought the pink one few fays ago and have to completely agree with you on the creasing and wearability. I bought mine to be specifically a highlight for the tear duct and brow bone though and I think it's working great for that! Love the post.♡
Jenna ♥ ♥
Northernbeauty85.blogspot.ca
*Home of Sociable♡Sundays*
Great post! I need to try these! xx
Have you tried the Jumbo pencil in Milk? I'm wondering what the difference is between Milk & Cottage Cheese. Maybe one is shimmery? x.
Very nice post!
Like the colours! ^^
I love the last one the most. I've actually wanted one like that so I can apply it on my waterline to make my eyes like brighter. I wish I have an NYX store in London! I'd rather go to a NYX store to buy products than buy them online.
Thanks for sharing :)
http://lifelivinginlondon.blogspot.co.uk/
lovely review!x
http://lilacbeam.blogspot.ca/
I appreciate you taking the time to comment over at mine. Happy Friday doll!
Love this product!
Would you like to follow each other? let me know!
http://alovelystyle.blogspot.com.es/
Oh I think NYX just opened up a store here in PH. It's in an SM Mall!
I have tried out the Jumbo Pencil in Milk and it's a good base for eye makeup! :)
xoxo,
Gelleesh.com
I have the Cottage Cheese one and have the creasing issue as well, but with a primer and maybe a light coat of a shadow to set it and it lasts forever. I really like the Strawberry Milk one, it's my favorite! Great review! <3
Shayne these pencils have been on my wishlist! Thank you for your review ^^ the colors are so pretty and shimmery I guess it's pretty for under eyes too <3 we have nyx here in Indonesia and I thought NYX is everywhere now D: but I still order nyx from online store lol cause the price is cheaper haha I love nyx too cause the products mostly are so adorable ^^
Nice review i love nyx jumbo pencils i use them under my shadows as an base and they work perfectly :)
http://www.glittergossip.com
wow i want all of them, thanks for the review!!! <3
Win a Free Pair of Shoes!
same here, I also wish we actually had it here in the Philippines. :< anyways, great review! thank you for sharing your thoughts about these pencils. :D Ciena
Our Sweet Wonderworld
If I am not mistaken, they already have a stall at SM Aura, Miss Shayne!
I believe they are already here? From what I heard they have a branch/stall in SM North EDSA Annex? I am not sure though. But if they are, I hope they carry all the NYX products and not just the round lipsticks like the stall in Trinoma. Great review, Shayne! :
Jenn
The Pink Lemonade Girl
thanks mohamed :)
i use cottage cheese a lot :) very functional. thanks for dropping by jackie!
what kind of shades do you prefer? :)
thanks D will check your blog in awhile :)
hahaha, i hate it too when that happens. there are some brands / items here that are originally cheap but comes out expensive because of taxes and such. thanks for nominating me yovi <3 i really appreciate it! :)
oh i can imagine that it can have an effect like that. it can be too shimmery sometimes and less satin finish. thanks for dropping by anni :)
too bad, we dont have it here too at least from what i know. i buy them from online sellers that ship them here. maybe you can find one there too :)
e bello, grazie seleny! :)
thank you shee ^^
they are very nice, any versatile since they are neutral :D thanks for dropping by :)
thats one color from their line that i really want to have! :D i heard that it is really a good eye shadow base and like you said it makes the colors pop :D
hi anna :) based on some comments posted here there are stores tat just opened in some SM department stores! :) none of them are near my place but im still glad that they finally reached our country :D
thanks too julia :)
thanks yige :)
thanks for dropping by here too jane ^^ ive heard of it but i cant find them in the mall, are they available only online? :) which of their products is your fave so i can check it out :D
hi romana :) i havent tried milk but you are right :) cottage cheese has shimmer so its like a pearly white color. milk is pure white and doesnt have shimmer. a lot of girls say that it is a really good eye shadow base and can make colors pop :D thanks for reading <3
thanks joao ^^
i share the same opinion jenna :) i mainly use them for that reason, it really gives my tear duct a nice luminous glow :D thank you so much for dropping by i really appreciate it :)
thanks lilac :)
have a nice weekend sam :)
me too huong :) i tend to enjoy buying cosmetics on the store vs buying them online. mostly because i like to experience them first before purchasing :D thanks for dropping by!
will check your blog in awhile rakel :)
everyone is saying that about milk pencil :D now i really want to buy it very badly haha. i didnt know that they opened in SM! :D :D thats really great news, thank you gellie! <33
they are nice :D at first i wanted to collect every color haha. thanks for dropping by carla <3
thank you emm :) i got to have the milk pencil i heard it is a very good eye shadow base :D
hi anna :D im glad we share the same opinion. i wonder if the darker shades crease a lot too? have you tried them maybe? :)
They sound really good, and they have beautiful colors! Nice review! You have a great blog! I'd love if you checked out my blog, and if you like it, can we follow each other on “GFC” (blog followers), and bloglovin? I promise I’ll follow you back <3
x❤x❤
“Saúde & Beleza – Health & Beauty”
hi misa :D that happens here too, most of the times the product online are cheaper because theres no tax. i hope you can get these soon tey are nice on the eyes and i think youll love them :)
Following you now on GFC :)
ciena ^^ i heard that we actually have nyx here already :D some girls said they just opened in some sm department stores :D thanks for dropping by!
huhu its too far :( but that means it will come near my place soon :D thank you thank you for letting me know kaye :)
i didnt even know they had it in trinoma ^^ thank you jenn! i hope they have the blushes because i really want to try those and i hope the prices are still as low as they can be :D
I totally loved this post!!! Really great inspiration! tell me if you would like to follow each other! I follow you back for sure – Lots of Love, Kyra♡
FOLLOW MY BLOG // TELL ME // I FOLLOW YOU BACK!
loved your review! so interesting and detailed!
would you like to follow each other?
http://www.fashionshores.blogspot.com
I love this post its so neat and percise and to the point! Thank you for the comment on my blog sugar, i appreciate it hun. I need me some more NYX! xx
http://shugahlicious-shug.blogspot.co.uk/
Oh these are on my wishlist. I want to get NYX Jumbo Pencil in Milk coz I often see beauty gurus use it as an eyeshadow base. :)
Wow! I love your blog! :)
Follow?
Visit my blog dyverst.blogspot.com
Really want this in white!
http://www.emtalks.co.uk
http://www.bloglovin.com/blog/3934124/emtalks x
I love the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk. It is a must have in my kit ^_^ makes a great base for striking eyeshadow colors. also love using this as tear duct highlight ^_^
I should try these out – I love cheaper drugstore products that work well :)
I like the Cashmere! The shade looks good for everyday use :)
awesome review..love the pink one!! thank u for visiting. added you on bloglovin. waiting for you :)
http://www.docdivatraveller.blogspot.in
i need to try them!
JOIN MY JUICY COUTURE BRACELET
GIVEAWAY ON MY BLOG!
http://WWW.AROUNDLUCIA.COM
actually NYX is officially here in the philippines! :) but i got their nyx jumbo pencil from a tiangge in greenhills! loving it! :) Anyway, i liked you fb page <3
thanks rakel :)
thanks maria :)
thanks kyra!
thanks victoria!
im glad you like it lea :)
me too :) i havent bought it yet but i really wanna get a hold of it soon :D
thanks katarzyna :)
hi em, the white ones are milk (matte) and cottage cheese (shimmer) :)
waah everybody is saying the same thing about the milk pencil ^^ i want it very badly
its a good deal caroline i hope you can try them soon :)
i use that color a lot with my UD palette, theres a gold color there that matches cashmere :D thanks for dropping by paola!
thanks for adding me on bloglovin, i appreciate it <3
thanks for dropping by lucia :)
i just found out about it after posting this blog ^^ such a great news! :) thanks for liking my page hazel <3
These pencils have actually been on my list for a very long time. I just don't see them in my local drugstores though.
Following you back!
7% Solution
I always see this but I don't really dive into it because I have a cream eye shadow palette. haha Great review Shayne :)
haha, what brand is your cream eye shadow? thanks sam :)
its hard to find them here too unless you purchase them online :D online store ftw! thanks aki :)
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencils are the best! i wish i can have the whole collection, all the colours are really pretty! and they're the perfect eye primer :) thanks for the lovely swatches Shayne <3
NEW POST: http://www.chriissydollxo.com
Let's connect at GFC and BLOGLOVIN'
me too! :) i went to phase wheni really really wanted to buy all of them and i had to stop myself ^^ thanks chrissy
I have Yogurt and a few other shades, but now I want Cashmere too. It looks great swatched.
fairestsfavorites.blogspot.com
it does :) it is one of my favorite colors <3 hope you can get one soon :)
i actually own over 10 of them. Unfortunately I barely use them except the milk one .As you said, because i have hooded eyes, they do not last on me very much. here is a post on them if you want to see which colors I have! http://visceralmaze.blogspot.com/2014/01/nyx-jumbo-eye-pencil-review-and-swatches.html
ooo you have a lot! :) i actually wanted to collect them all haha, good thing i didnt bec i realized that as i collect more eyeshadows the less i use these chubby sticks, with the exception of cottage cheese – its a good eye primer :D visiting your link now :)
Thanks for this Shayne. I tried using the pencil with and without primers – it is better to use it along with primers. :)
xo,
~Pauline @Kallony
they are also nice to use as actual primers under eye shadows :D milk should be really nice under colored matte eye shadows, i dont have it yet so i use cottage cheese instead :D thank you too pauline!
First I want to apaologize for my late replies to your endearing comments and then i want to thank you for being such a nice and sweet friend.
They look really awesome! It's annoying that they don't sell that brand here yet. Seems that they have quite a few products that are worth the try and are not expensive. Like those jumbo pencils! Cashmere and Sparkle Nude are really beautiful and neutral. I'm sure they work for many looks.
Growing up I always reveived chocolate eggs as well, but now they make a lot of bunnies and I thought it would be an interesting change. And the bunnies are also smaller than the eggs!! But my skin is very angry at me right now…from eating all that chocolate in just two days.
Take care.
http://momodicted.blogspot.pt/
aw thanks xana :) thats totally okay, i too have been m.i.a lately. the egg chocolates are also sold here during winter but i havent seen bunny chocolates ^^ if ever youre planning on trying their jumbo pencils i would suggest getting “milk” shade its a really good base for colored eye shadows, makes the colors pop :)